THE BILL ITSELF
SB 30
Relief of the Estate of Lisa-Maria Carter by the University of South Florida
Florida Senate - 2027 (NP) SB 30 By Senator DiCeglie 18-00055A-27 202730__
1
A bill to be entitled
2
An act for the relief of the Estate of Lisa-Maria
3
Carter; providing an appropriation to compensate the
4
estate for injuries and damages sustained by Ms.
5
Carter as a result of the negligence of physicians
6
employed by the Board of Trustees of the University of
7
South Florida; providing a limitation on compensation
8
and the payment of attorney fees; providing an
9
effective date.
11
WHEREAS, on November 1, 2010, Lisa-Maria Carter underwent a
12
laparoscopic hysterectomy and related gynecological surgical
13
procedures at Tampa General Hospital, performed by physicians
14
employed by the Board of Trustees of the University of South
15
Florida, and
16
WHEREAS, the surgery was expected to be a routine,
17
minimally invasive procedure, and Ms. Carter was to be
18
discharged following her postoperative recovery, and
19
WHEREAS, during the surgical procedure, Ms. Carter
20
sustained an injury to her small intestine which was not
21
recognized before the completion of the operation, and
22
WHEREAS, in the days after the surgery, Ms. Carter
23
experienced severe abdominal pain, hypotension, tachycardia,
24
respiratory distress, persistent signs of infection, abdominal
25
distention, worsening laboratory findings, and other clinical
26
indicators demonstrating that she was suffering from a
27
catastrophic postoperative complication, and
28
WHEREAS, despite repeated evaluations and the continued
29
deterioration of her condition, the small intestine injury was
30
not timely diagnosed or surgically repaired, allowing intestinal
31
contents to leak into the abdominal cavity, which resulted in
32
sepsis, septic shock, and multiple life-threatening
33
complications, and
34
WHEREAS, physicians employed by the Board of Trustees of
35
the University of South Florida transferred Ms. Carter to the
36
intensive care unit to manage her deteriorating condition,
37
including the use of vasopressors, while continuing to direct
38
and manage her medical care and remaining responsible for
39
prescribing appropriate antibiotic treatment, which was not
40
timely provided, and
41
WHEREAS, expert testimony in a court of law established
42
that Ms. Carter was in septic shock before being transferred to
43
the intensive care unit while under the care of physicians
44
employed by the Board of Trustees of the University of South
45
Florida, yet antibiotics were not timely prescribed, and
46
WHEREAS, emergency exploratory surgery ultimately revealed
47
a significant small intestine injury with extensive
48
contamination throughout the abdominal cavity, requiring
49
immediate surgical intervention and prolonged critical care
50
treatment, and
51
WHEREAS, as a result of septic shock and the failure to
52
timely prescribe antibiotics, Ms. Carter suffered catastrophic
53
injuries, and
54
WHEREAS, before these events, Ms. Carter was an
55
accomplished professional preparing to deploy to Iraq as a
56
civilian intelligence analyst supporting the United States
57
Department of Defense, and the injuries she sustained
58
permanently ended her career, eliminated her earning capacity,
59
and fundamentally altered every aspect of her life, and
60
WHEREAS, Ms. Carter filed suit against the Board of
61
Trustees of the University of South Florida in the Circuit Court
62
of the 13th Judicial Circuit in and for Hillsborough County,
63
case number 12-CA-009942, alleging medical negligence in the
64
medical care rendered by physicians employed by the Board of
65
Trustees of the University of South Florida, and
66
WHEREAS, on January 26, 2018, a jury returned a verdict in
67
favor of Ms. Carter in the amount of $109,760,930, plus taxable
68
costs and attorney fees as awarded by the court, and
69
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees of the University of South
70
Florida appealed the verdict and resulting judgment, arguing
71
that the intensive care unit physicians should have been
72
included on the verdict form pursuant to Fabre, notwithstanding
73
the Board of Trustees’ contractual responsibility for such
74
physicians negligence and the hospital’s continued management of
75
Ms. Carter’s care during her hospitalization, and
76
WHEREAS, the Second District Court of Appeal reversed the
77
judgment and remanded the matter for a new trial after
78
concluding that the intensive care unit physicians should have
79
been included on the verdict form, and
80
WHEREAS, following subsequent proceedings, on December 29,
81
2021, a final judgment was entered against the Board of Trustees
82
of the University of South Florida in the amount of $1.05
83
million, which is subject to the sovereign immunity limitations
84
contained in s. 768.28, Florida Statutes (2010), and
85
WHEREAS, following the entry of the final judgment, Ms.
86
Carter died, and Artis D. Carter II was duly appointed the
87
personal representative of the Estate of Lisa-Maria Carter, and
88
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees of the University of South
89
Florida has taken the position that no payment of the judgment
90
will be made absent legislative authorization through the
91
enactment of a claims bill, and
92
WHEREAS, this claim bill is for the recovery of the excess
93
judgment in the amount of $850,000, NOW, THEREFORE,
95
Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
97
Section 1. The facts stated in the preamble to this act are
98
found and declared to be true.
99
Section 2. The sum of $850,000 is appropriated from the
100
General Revenue Fund to the Board of Trustees of the University
101
of South Florida for the relief of the Estate of Lisa-Maria
102
Carter for injuries and damages sustained, by and through the
103
estate’s personal representative, Artis D. Carter II.
104
Section 3. The Chief Financial Officer is directed to draw
105
a warrant in favor of the Estate of Lisa-Maria Carter in the sum
106
of $850,000 upon funds of the Board of Trustees of the
107
University of South Florida in the State Treasury and to pay the
108
same out of such funds in the State Treasury.
109
Section 4. The amount paid by the Board of Trustees of the
110
University of South Florida pursuant to s. 768.28, Florida
111
Statutes (2010), and the amount awarded under this act are
112
intended to provide the sole compensation for all present and
113
future claims arising out of the factual situation described in
114
this act which resulted in injuries and damages to Lisa-Maria
115
Carter. The total amount paid for attorney fees relating to this
116
claim may not exceed 25 percent of the total amount awarded
117
under this act.
118
Section 5. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law.