THE BILL ITSELF
SB 40
Relief of H.H. by the Department of Children and Families
Florida Senate - 2027 (NP) SB 40 By Senator Davis 5-00045-27 202740__
1
A bill to be entitled
2
An act for the relief of H.H. by the Department of
3
Children and Families; providing an appropriation to
4
compensate H.H. for injuries and damages sustained as
5
a result of the negligence of the department;
6
providing legislative intent; providing a limitation
7
on compensation and the payment of certain fees and
8
costs; providing an effective date.
10
WHEREAS, on May 3, 2017, H.H. was a healthy 18-month-old
11
developing normally, when the Department of Children and
12
Families received its first child abuse hotline report regarding
13
H.H., which alleged substance abuse by H.H.’s mother and
14
stepfather and that the mother and stepfather were selling drugs
15
out of, and harboring a fugitive in, their home, and
16
WHEREAS, during the course of its investigation of the
17
initial child abuse hotline report, the department discovered
18
that the stepfather had been released from the Department of
19
Corrections 7 months before initiation of the Department of
20
Children and Families’ investigation after being incarcerated
21
for 3 and a half years, was on probation, had been married to
22
the mother for only 1 month and had been dating the mother for
23
only 3 months before initiation of the department’s
24
investigation, and had a significant and dangerous criminal
25
history that showed a pattern of impulsivity and violence, and
26
WHEREAS, at the time of the initial child abuse hotline
27
report, the stepfather had been involved in at least 35
28
incidents resulting in police reports, and his criminal history,
29
ranging from 2003 through 2013, included a 2003 charge for
30
driving under the influence, marijuana possession, and drug
31
equipment possession; a 2003 charge for driving under the
32
influence and possession of liquor by a person under the age of
33
21; a 2003 charge for driving while his license was suspended or
34
revoked, including a prior suspension for refusal to submit to a
35
lawful test of breath; a 2003 charge for burglary; 2004 felony
36
convictions for possession of cocaine, possession of drug
37
paraphernalia, and burglary of a dwelling, for which he served
38
concurrent sentences of 270 days and 55 days in jail; a 2004
39
arrest for resisting an officer without violence during a
40
disturbance; a 2005 charging affidavit for violation of a court
41
order and making threats toward his girlfriend’s parents; a 2007
42
battery charge; a 2007 felony conviction for fleeing and
43
eluding; a 2009 arrest for violation of probation relating to
44
drug charges; a 2009 charge for marijuana possession, violation
45
of driver license restrictions, and drug equipment possession; a
46
2010 arrest for possession of a controlled substance and
47
possession of a firearm by a convicted felon; a 2010 arrest for
48
involvement in a marijuana-growing operation and the cultivation
49
and manufacturing of cannabis; 2011 felony convictions for
50
possession of a Schedule II controlled substance, possession of
51
a firearm by a convicted felon, manufacture of cannabis,
52
possession of cocaine, fleeing and eluding, burglary of a
53
dwelling, possession of drug paraphernalia, driving while his
54
license was suspended, battery of a law enforcement officer, and
55
escape, for which he was sentenced to two 366-day sentences in
56
prison; and 2013 felony convictions for resisting arrest with
57
violence, fleeing or attempting to elude, driving while his
58
license was suspended or revoked, battery on a law enforcement
59
officer, and escape, for which he was sentenced to 4 years in
60
prison, and
61
WHEREAS, during the course of the department’s
62
investigation of the initial child abuse hotline report, H.H.’s
63
stepfather refused to submit to a drug test, and
64
WHEREAS, during the course of the department’s
65
investigation of the initial abuse report, H.H.’s mother
66
admitted to smoking marijuana and tested positive for marijuana,
67
and
68
WHEREAS, despite the department’s discoveries regarding
69
risk of harm to H.H. during the investigation, the department
70
failed to thoroughly investigate the child abuse hotline report
71
by failing to speak with any person who may have had information
72
regarding H.H.’s safety, such as family members or the
73
stepfather’s probation officer, and failing to request relevant
74
records and to refer the family to appropriate services, and
75
WHEREAS, despite the department’s knowledge of the
76
potential risk for harm to H.H. as a result of the initial
77
investigation, the department incorrectly assessed the danger to
78
H.H. as “no present danger” under the care of her mother and
79
stepfather, and
80
WHEREAS, on June 2, 2017, while the initial investigation
81
remained open, the department received a second child abuse
82
hotline report regarding H.H., alleging substance misuse by the
83
mother and stepfather and neglect of H.H. by the mother, and
84
WHEREAS, between June 2 and June 28, 2017, the department
85
failed to investigate the allegations of the second abuse
86
report, failed to conduct a home visit at the family’s residence
87
to observe H.H., and failed to refer the family to appropriate
88
services, and
89
WHEREAS, on June 28, 2017, the department visited a motel
90
to which the family had relocated, but failed to conduct any
91
additional investigation in connection with the second abuse
92
report, and
93
WHEREAS, on July 2, 2017, the department closed both
94
investigations with no findings without conducting a thorough
95
investigation or ensuring H.H.’s safety, and
96
WHEREAS, on September 4, 2017, only 2 months after closing
97
the first two cases alleging abuse of H.H., the department
98
received four additional child abuse hotline reports regarding
99
severe abuse and neglect of H.H., and
100
WHEREAS, on September 4, 2017, H.H. was admitted to the
101
hospital with life-threatening injuries, and
102
WHEREAS, upon admission to the hospital, H.H. was
103
unconscious and unresponsive; had a severe traumatic head
104
injury; had multiple areas of bleeding in her brain; had severe
105
brain swelling caused by repetitive abusive head trauma; had eye
106
injuries; was in respiratory failure requiring ventilator
107
support; was placed in a medically induced coma; underwent two
108
cranioplasties to remove parts of her skull to allow her brain
109
swelling to go down; received various other intensive medical
110
interventions and treatment; and was determined to be the victim
111
of severe, prolonged, repeated, life-threatening physical abuse
112
that caused permanent damage, and
113
WHEREAS, due to the significance of her injuries, H.H.
114
remained in the hospital for 109 days, and
115
WHEREAS, a law enforcement investigation determined that
116
H.H. had been physically abused, neglected, and tortured by her
117
mother and stepfather, and
118
WHEREAS, the department only removed H.H. from her mother’s
119
care and placed her in its custody after the law enforcement
120
investigation, and
121
WHEREAS, as a result of the law enforcement investigation,
122
H.H.’s mother was charged with and convicted of aggravated child
123
abuse and child neglect causing great bodily harm and was
124
sentenced to 40 years in prison, and H.H.’s stepfather was
125
charged with and convicted of possession of a firearm by a
126
convicted felon, aggravated child abuse, and child abuse and
127
child neglect causing great bodily harm and was sentenced to 25
128
years in prison, and
129
WHEREAS, as a consequence of the department’s negligence
130
and failure to take protective action, H.H. suffered
131
catastrophic and permanent injuries, including, but not limited
132
to, permanent traumatic brain damage, cerebral palsy,
133
encephalomalacia, ventriculomegaly, profound developmental
134
delays, the inability to walk or talk, the inability to sit up
135
independently, dysphagia, the inability to eat without use of a
136
feeding tube, posttraumatic epilepsy and seizures that
137
necessitated surgery and the implantation of a vagus nerve
138
stimulation device in her chest, spasticity, neurostorming
139
dysfunction, obstructive sleep apnea, chronic constipation and
140
gastroesophageal reflux disease, and chronic lung disease and
141
restrictive lung disease, and
142
WHEREAS, H.H. has also been treated for acute respiratory
143
failure, anemia, transaminitis, hyperglycemia, fevers,
144
tachycardia, candida stomatitis, and acute tracheitis, and
145
WHEREAS, in November 2022, H.H. underwent corpus
146
callosotomy surgery to treat seizures that were occurring
147
multiple times daily, and she had another brain surgery in
148
January 2025, and
149
WHEREAS, H.H. will require additional brain surgical
150
procedures in the future and will be catheterized to assist with
151
urination, and
152
WHEREAS, H.H.’s care is monitored by multiple physicians,
153
including specialists in pediatrics, palliative care, neurology,
154
neurosurgery, gastroenterology, pulmonology, orthopedics, and
155
urology, and
156
WHEREAS, H.H. receives physical therapy, occupational
157
therapy, and speech therapy, and
158
WHEREAS, H.H. requires and will continue to require
159
constant care, monitoring, supervision, various therapies,
160
multiple specialist services, and supportive care throughout the
161
remainder of her life, and
162
WHEREAS, as the state agency charged under chapter 39,
163
Florida Statutes, with operating the child welfare system in
164
this state, including conducting child protective investigations
165
to ensure child safety and to prevent further harm to children,
166
the department failed in its duty to ensure H.H.’s safety and
167
protect her from harm, and
168
WHEREAS, following a jury trial, a verdict was rendered on
169
December 8, 2023, in the amount of $15 million in favor of H.H.,
170
and
171
WHEREAS, the jury found that, but for the department’s
172
negligence in failing to complete a thorough child protective
173
investigation to ensure H.H.’s safety and to protect H.H. from
174
further abuse and neglect, which was its primary duty, H.H.
175
would not have suffered catastrophic and permanent injuries, and
176
WHEREAS, $200,000 of the jury award was recovered from the
177
department, which has exhausted the sovereign immunity limits
178
set forth in s. 768.28, Florida Statutes, and
179
WHEREAS, the trial court entered a cost judgment awarding
180
taxable costs in the amount of $126,639.56 to H.H., to be paid
181
by the department, and
182
WHEREAS, a total of $14,926,639.56, representing $14.8
183
million in excess of the sovereign immunity limits and
184
$126,639.56 in costs awarded to H.H., plus interest, remains
185
unpaid by the department, and
186
WHEREAS, H.H. is responsible for payment of attorney fees
187
and all remaining costs and expenses relating to this claim,
188
subject to the limitations set forth in this act, NOW,
189
THEREFORE,
191
Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
193
Section 1. The facts stated in the preamble to this act are
194
found and declared to be true.
195
Section 2. The sum of $14,926,639.56 is appropriated from
196
the General Revenue Fund to the Department of Children and
197
Families for the relief of H.H. for injuries and damages
198
sustained as a result of the department’s negligence.
199
Section 3. The Chief Financial Officer is directed to draw
200
a warrant in favor of H.H., payable to an irrevocable trust
201
created for the exclusive use and benefit of H.H., in the sum of
202
$14,926,639.56 upon funds of the Department of Children and
203
Families in the State Treasury and to pay the same out of such
204
funds in the State Treasury.
205
Section 4. It is the intent of the Legislature that all
206
government liens, including Medicaid liens, resulting from the
207
treatment and care of H.H. for the occurrences described in this
208
act be waived and paid by the state.
209
Section 5. The amount paid by the Department of Children
210
and Families pursuant to s. 768.28, Florida Statutes, and the
211
amount awarded under this act are intended to provide the sole
212
compensation for all present and future claims arising out of
213
the factual situation described in this act which resulted in
214
injuries and damages to H.H. The total amount paid for attorney
215
fees relating to this claim may not exceed 25 percent of the
216
total amount awarded under this act.
217
Section 6. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law.